When You Lead the Horse to the Water, But It Still Won't Drink
× Search

Sprocket Websites - Blog / News / Updates

When You Lead the Horse to the Water, But It Still Won't Drink
Kate Gingold
/ Categories: The Sprocket Report

If you find this helpful, pay it forward! More after the article...

When You Lead the Horse to the Water, But It Still Won't Drink

Sixteenth in a series

Since the beginning of the year, we have been experimenting with Facebook (Meta) advertising and letting you look over our shoulder. There was a bump in our road, so take a look:

If you remember, we created four versions of our ad and let all of them run for a short time as an A/B test. At the end of the trial period, there was a definite winner, so we shut off the other three and just ran the winning version.

Combing through the Facebook analytics, the numbers looked good. First off, the ad was seen by the right audience, which for us is mid-career women and men as they tend to be in management positions with the power to make website decisions.

Second, the ad enjoyed a decent reach even with a limited budget. We didn’t want our team resources to be overwhelmed, so we weren’t looking for millions of impressions. The tens of thousands of impressions our ad received seemed to be plenty for generating a few leads.

Of those thousands of impressions, our ad received quite a number of clicks. We did the research on what a reasonable click-through rate might be for our specific industry because there is a big difference between the CTR for cute shoes and the CTR for athlete’s foot medication.

Across all industries, the average click-through rate in March 2023 was 1.49%. Our ad’s click-through rate was 4.77%, which seemed like a great return for all our hard work adhering to Meta’s advertising rules and suggestions.

Following through, we also checked our Google Analytics reports for the same period. Sure enough, thousands of new visitors arrived on the SEO audit page and we learned something new about GA4. We suspect there will be many more new GA4 quirks to share since the rollout just happened last month, but here’s one specific to Facebook ads: In the Reports Snapshot in your GA4 account, traffic from paid ads will be counted as “Organic Social” until you update your UTM parameters. We won’t get into this right now, so call us if you have questions.

Everything was playing out just as we expected – and that’s when we hit the bump. While we were successful in bringing lots of horses to the water, not a single horse took a drink. That is, no one actually ran the free SEO audit report for their business.

We were surprised, naturally, but we’ve been in this business a long time and have seen this happen before. So, what do we do next? We’ll do the same things that we would advise our clients to do. If the audience is interested enough in the ad to click through, then something on the landing page is scaring them off. We just need to figure out what. Now we’ll try reworking the message, changing up the look, reviewing the offering, and testing out different approaches to see what resonates.

Sure, we’re disappointed, but it’s way too soon to give up. We’re going back to the drawing board, knowing more now than we did before, which means we are getting closer to success. Have you have experienced disappointment in your marketing efforts, too? If you have trouble finding and figuring out your analytics to learn what went wrong, give us a call. We’d be happy to discuss it with you.

Photo by Trungtuyen Cao

Did you enjoy this article? Was it helpful? Insightful?
Then please share it! Post it on your favorite Social Media platform(s) so your followers see it.
It's easy. Just click on any of the social icons below and we'll do the heavy lifting for you.
Oh yeah, leave a comment below. We'd love to hear from you. Thanks for visiting!

652 Rate this article:
Kate Gingold

Kate GingoldKate Gingold

I have been writing a blog with web marketing tips and techniques every other week since 2003. In addition to blogging and client content writing, I write books and a blog on local history.

Other posts by Kate Gingold
Contact author Full biography

Full biography

I have been writing a blog with web marketing tips and techniques every other week since 2003. In addition to blogging and client content writing, I write books and a blog on local history.

Previous Article SEO, Social Media Marketing, and Content Marketing - Why Your Business Needs All Three
Next Article How Can You Market Your Business if You Can't Answer These Basic Questions?

2 comments on article "When You Lead the Horse to the Water, But It Still Won't Drink"

Avatar image

Jerilyn Willin

Great article. Liked the way it took me step-by-step through your process. Success...success...WHAT? I think many people, myself included, stop when no one "takes". Instead, you folks said, "what s wrong with this last step?" Believe it or not, I'm not sure I ever asked that question. Thanks..

Avatar image

Kate Gingold

Thanks for commenting, Jerilyn! Successful marketing is as much of an art form as a science, isn't it? Now, back to analyzing and experimenting...

Leave a comment

This form collects your name, email, IP address and content so that we can keep track of the comments placed on the website. For more info check our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use where you will get more info on where, how and why we store your data.
Add comment

Contact author


Stay In-The-Know...

Via QR Code

... With Every-Other-Week Tips!

Every other Tuesday, you'll receive the Sprocket Report completely free! Learn the latest business tip or news about what's currently happening in internet marketing. You get:

  • A web marketing tip from Kate
  • Another one from Breanne, and
  • Bonus! Tips curated from around the web

That's three valuable posts that you can read, plus a quick look at upcoming events and what's being discussed on Twitter. 

You'll want to get this info for yourself, in your own inbox. It's easy!

Type your email in the box above. OR scroll to the bottom of any page on this site. We have our subscription box there, too!

We NEVER give out your email address to anybody else and we don't flood you with ads. It's just good, free information. 

About Us

We turn surfers into visitors and visitors into customers.

We'll make you a beautiful, interactive website. Then we'll help drive traffic to it.

Read Archived Articles




Get The Sprocket Report


Terms Of UsePrivacy StatementCopyright © 2024 by Sprocket Websites, Inc.
Back To Top