Power Up Better Email Conversion with this "Secret Sauce"
× Search

Sprocket Websites - Blog / News / Updates

Power Up Better Email Conversion with this "Secret Sauce"
Kate Gingold
/ Categories: The Sprocket Report

Power Up Better Email Conversion with this "Secret Sauce"

Fifteenth in a series

If you’re disappointed with your email marketing results, it’s time to review what you have now and rework it using the latest proven techniques. Read on as we spill the “secret sauce.”

We shared email marketing trends last time. Now let’s examine the specific elements that are being used in today’s most successful email campaigns so you can incorporate them into your own marketing. These aren’t difficult actions to take and yet, so many don’t get it right.  

Start with the best subject line.
If you lose your reader when they’re skimming subject lines in their inbox, it doesn’t matter what else you provide in your email. Do your absolute best at writing something so compelling they won’t delete you without even opening your message. 

What’s compelling? Research says your subject line should be short for easy scanning and to make sure it isn’t cut off by Outlook or similar tools. In that limited space, use meaningful words, especially ones associated with action. Try to create a sense of urgency such as “Today Only,” “Last Chance,” or “Going Fast.” By the way, stats say (and you probably already know this!) that a negative message gets people to respond more often than a positive one.

Once you’ve done you’re very best, do it again. Now take those two and test them against each other. Use the one with the most opens. Better yet, improve on it and test again. Getting folks to open because of your subject line is your biggest challenge.

Map out your email content.
Once you have caught your recipient’s eye, don’t squander the opportunity! Your email content needs to fulfill the interest you piqued – and the sooner the better! 

Identify the pain that your product or service will relieve and make that possible transformation clear right up front while you still have their attention. For example, instead of introducing your real estate business, point out how irritating it is to work in a small, outdated kitchen and how you can find them that new, spacious kitchen they long for. 

You can include more details later, but organize your content so that it’s easy to scan. Use bullet points and headlines to highlight the most important parts, but be careful not to go overboard because when everything is “important,” nothing stands out anymore. 

Take care when creating your Call to Action and only include one per email. You want to be crystal clear about what you are asking your reader to do so it is easy for them to do it. Like the subject line, test your two best efforts to see which resonates better.  

Connect with your prospective customer.
This is where your customer persona research comes in handy. Knowing your audience fully is crucial for creating email marketing that they will respond to. Consider the tone of your message, the types of images, even the best time of day to reach them. 

Personalization is currently really big in marketing. Addressing your recipient by name is one way to connect personally, but so is acknowledging where they are on the buyer’s journey. Your message for previous customers should be different than that for new ones. You might also want to segment your list by age or location or some other trait for personalized messages. 

Earn respect by being respectful.
The last ingredient in this “secret sauce” is maintaining an impeccable reputation so you aren’t banished as spam. Good design quality is the first step, with correct grammar and punctuation. Using your logo and branding across all of your marketing from email to website to social media helps people recognize your business as legitimate. Bombarding them with mail will get you deleted, but contacting them on a regular basis establishes familiarity. Finally, don’t use just any excuse to push a hard sell. Keep your messages appropriate to the circumstance.

When you’re running an email campaign, it's smart to set yourself realistic goals. The average email conversion rate was 15.22% in 2021, which may sound underwhelming, but is far better than the 2.5% conversion rate of paid advertising, so it’s worth the effort. If you’re interested in launching an email campaign but need help, the Sprocket Websites team is standing by to assist you. Just give us a call to talk it over.

Read the next post in this series.

Photo by Mikhail Nilov

Previous Article What's Worse Than Failure to Launch? Holding Your Business Back in Fear of Failure!
Next Article Instagram Is Necessary to Your Business Success! (Or Is It?)
274 Rate this article:
Kate Gingold

Kate GingoldKate Gingold

I have been writing a blog with web marketing tips and techniques every other week since 2003. In addition to blogging and client content writing, I write books and a blog on local history.

Other posts by Kate Gingold
Contact author Full biography

Full biography

I have been writing a blog with web marketing tips and techniques every other week since 2003. In addition to blogging and client content writing, I write books and a blog on local history.


Leave a comment

This form collects your name, email, IP address and content so that we can keep track of the comments placed on the website. For more info check our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use where you will get more info on where, how and why we store your data.
Add comment

Contact author


Stay In-The-Know...

Via QR Code

... With Every-Other-Week Tips!

Every other Tuesday, you'll receive the Sprocket Report completely free! Learn the latest business tip or news about what's currently happening in internet marketing. You get:

  • A web marketing tip from Kate
  • Another one from Breanne, and
  • Bonus! Tips curated from around the web

That's three valuable posts that you can read, plus a quick look at upcoming events and what's being discussed on Twitter. 

You'll want to get this info for yourself, in your own inbox. It's easy!

Type your email in the box above. OR scroll to the bottom of any page on this site. We have our subscription box there, too!

We NEVER give out your email address to anybody else and we don't flood you with ads. It's just good, free information. 

About Us

We turn surfers into visitors and visitors into customers.

We'll make you a beautiful, interactive website. Then we'll help drive traffic to it.

Read Archived Articles




Get The Sprocket Report


Terms Of UsePrivacy StatementCopyright © 2022 by Sprocket Websites, Inc.
Back To Top